Success Stories
Prior success does not indicate or guarantee success in any future legal representation. Constitutes attorney advertising.
Water, water everywhere …
“Our client and another party were both alleged to have polluted the groundwater at an industrial facility surrounded by hundreds of residences with private drinking-water wells. We filed litigation against multiple carriers seeking the insurance necessary to defend...
My fire case is exploding
“When our client’s $30M construction project, 75% complete, was destroyed by arson, they turned to us to secure their builders’ risk coverage necessary to rebuild. Problem: neither the contractor nor the security company could establish adherence to the protective...
My explosion case is on fire
“One morning, at 5:30 a.m., I received a phone call from a frantic client: ‘Our plant just exploded, and I need the best OSHA lawyer in America within the next 45 minutes.’ Within two hours, we retained that lawyer 3000 miles away, and for the next several years...
We do windows. Lots
“Full coverage: A U.S. subsidiary of a $90 billion petrochemical company was sued by a window manufacturer in a putative class action alleging defects in insulating glass sealants used in $4 billion worth of windows over a 20-year period. We twice defeated class...
“Conspicuous’ means hidden, right?”
“Our client, a landlord, was sued by a tenant for alleged exposure to lead paint in the rented unit. Problem: every applicable policy had a lead paint exclusion. We demonstrated that the lead paint exclusion, which crept into the policy years before, had not been...
Kneecaps still intact
“We defended a U.S. sealant manufacturer against a $2.1 million litigation in Quebec, Canada. The mobbed-up plaintiff – who referred to me affectionately (?) as “Mr. Hollywood” – claimed our client was responsible for the failure of 17,000 insulating glass units the...
Don’t spoliate the Subway Footlong
“Our client was sued in a small midwestern town where the plaintiff was the largest employer, with one judge in town for the last 25 years. Subway was the only fine-dining option available. The plaintiff manufactured housing components with our client’s materials. ...
A fortunate outcome
“On September 10, 2001, I landed in New York City for a mediation with an insurance company in which we needed to secure coverage for about $12M in construction products litigations filed against our client in California, Wisconsin, and New York. The case also...
Somewhat afraid of heights
“A roofing contractor in Chicago blamed our client, a construction product manufacturer, for supposedly causing his roofs to become mushy, leaky, and sticky. One million dollars of icky roofs. During our inspection of one of the roofs, the homeowner called 9-1-1. ...
Not afraid to dig deep
“At the time, it was the largest bankruptcy ever in California. We represented the creditors’ committee in the pursuit of environmental coverage against 16 insurance carriers. The case involved underground storage tanks and bunkers in multiple locations in central...
Really bad negotiating; really big win
“$10 million workplace chemical exposure lawsuit against 30 defendants. Everyone settled. Not us. We were the last defendant standing on the eve of trial, and plaintiff’s counsel berated us: ‘You are the worst negotiator I’ve ever met.’ Next day, she dismissed the...
Strike first. Strike hard. Win big.
“Our client’s customer, a substantial construction products concern in California, owed our client about $1.5M. The customer refused to pay, saying the products sold by my client didn’t work, and threatened to file a $10M litigation in California. We said, “we’ll...
Independence Day!
“Like most jurisdictions, California grants the insured the right to select its own independent counsel, at the insurer’s expense (at panel rates), to defend an underlying case when the insurer’s reservation letter creates a conflict for appointed counsel. In our...
Texas Sue ‘em
“The insurance company had repeatedly denied indemnity coverage for a massive construction-defect litigation. “No property damage” . . . same old, same old. On the eve of trial and running out of options, we filed a coverage lawsuit in an unanticipated jurisdiction...
Let all doubt subside
“Our construction-industry client was sued as a result of an accident in which a construction worker lost his life. The insurance company denied coverage based on a subsidence exclusion in the policy. We first obtained a defense for our client under another party’s...
With us, it’s not an act
“On stage, this world-famous performance artist has an act that thrills some and nauseates others. At deposition, he comes across as a highly articulate professional. “On stage, it’s all an act,” he testified. For us, it was not an act when we won him full insurance...
It’s a bloody business
“We prosecuted and successfully resolved a $100 million contract claim on behalf of a Spanish pharmaceutical company against a California supplier of blood plasma in an International Chamber of Commerce arbitration venued in London, governed by California and Dutch...
Swimming with the tiles
“We disposed of a claim by a major university involving alleged defects in all of its many swimming pools. Our client paid nothing to settle the claim. We used technical evidence to persuade the university and other impacted parties that our client’s product did not...
You have the right to remain silent
“In a massive putative class action claiming $1.5 billion, the plaintiff neglected to plead the basis for jurisdiction. Knowing this would easily be addressed by amending the complaint with nothing gained, we kept silent. The judge noticed a year later and dismissed...
‘Not gonna do it; wouldn’t be prudent’ (Did it!)
“Due to its size, our settlement of a multimillion-dollar proceeding against multiple federal regulators required the approval of the President of the United States (then George H.W. Bush) and the Secretary of the Treasury. Our client was the parent company of a...
Didn’t go to jail; collected more than $200
“I sat in the front row of the courtroom, listening to the argument in the case on calendar just before ours (one in which we represented a Fortune 500 company in the prosecution of a trademark infringement action). The criminal defendant standing before the judge...
Critical Commas Confer Coverage
“The insurance company denied coverage of attorneys’ fees in an employment practices claim against a public utility based on an exclusion in the policy. We fought back, pointing out that two missing commas rendered the exclusion ambiguous. The insurance company...
Dog fight
“A landlord was sued by pedestrians who had been brutally attacked by a pit bull being walked by the landlord’s tenant. The landlord had never even seen the pit bull and was unaware of its existence. The insurance company denied coverage because the attack took...
Huh!?
“In a one-sentence denial, a consortium of insurance companies rejected coverage, based on purportedly late notice, of a claim asserted against our client, an HOA. The insurance program was convoluted to say the least. We picked it apart over a weekend,...
Don’t stop ‘til you’re at the top
“We went to the top of an insurance company to resolve a travel insurance claim for a client who suffered an illness episode during an insured trip. The insurance company had twice denied coverage because our client, the insured, had not had an overnight hospital...
Icing on the cake
“Our client suffered an extreme accident while traveling, breaking his neck and back. Thankfully, he is on the mend. The seemingly reputable and well-regarded travel insurance company engaged in delay after delay, leaving our client and his family to their own...
Self-Care
"Our client was on safari for a professional endeavor when his pulmonary condition flared at high elevation. He prudently returned home for medical treatment. His insurer denied coverage because he had not sought medical treatment before returning home. The...
RTF insurance policy!
“When you own a Stradivarius violin worth well more than $10M, it had better be properly insured. Our client lends such a violin to great artists for major performances, and often the violin is in the hands of the artists or performing arts organizations. ...
Testimonials
At Scheidemantle Law Group, client satisfaction is our Number One priority.
Prior success does not indicate or guarantee success in any future legal representation. Constitutes attorney advertising.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
Kimberly Dabertin
Director of Environmental, Health, Safety & Regulatory, Bostik, Inc. (retired).
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“David exemplifies the traits of the best lawyers in the largest law firms--keenly intelligent and knowledgeable, creative in resolving disputes, and highly client-focused.”
Ken Kastner
Environmental Partner, Hogan Lovells LLP (retired).
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
David Scheidemantle represented me after my homeowners insurance company wrongfully refused to pay my insurance claim, which involved significant construction repair costs. As a lawyer myself, it was with great pleasure that I was able to sit back and relax, knowing that David’s obvious expertise in this area would bring success. David and his firm worked relentlessly on my behalf, resulting in the payment of 100% of my claim. He is ethical, talented, and focused on success. I highly recommend him.”
Patti Paniccia
Adjunct Professor, Pepperdine University School of Law
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“Experienced, brilliant, and creative, David is the attorney to call to resolve complex business litigation matters. I retained David as outside counsel on a highly sensitive case. His expertise, calm manner and innovative approach led to a very favorable outcome for our company. David has my highest recommendation.”
Jean Murrell Adams
Award-winning Special Education Attorney, Author, and Entrepreneur
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“David is a highly skilled litigator who brings both creativity and polish to all of his cases. His attention to detail and strong inter-personal skills make him extremely effective both in the courtroom and in the boardroom. I strongly recommend him as a both a lawyer and a person.”
Aaron Allan
Environmental and Energy Partner at Glaser Weil, LLP
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“I was recently represented by David Scheidemantle in a real estate case involving fraudulent conveyance. At risk was the clear title of a parsonage belonging to our non-profit ministry for nearly 10 years. The case was complex, and mostly beyond my ability to navigate on my own. I was impressed with the diligent and prompt manner in which David addressed all aspects of the case. He executed every move flawlessly and with a high level of professionalism. His knowledge of the law, coupled with the ability to apply it effectively, was commendable. Working with David was a positive experience resulting in an excellent outcome!”
Tim Malki
President, Middle East Gospel Outreach
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“I had the pleasure of working alongside David as co-defense counsel a few years back. David was insightful, efficient, and strategic while handling the case for his client. David’s clients surely benefit from his combination of intellect and emotional intelligence.”
Lauren Bushman
Attorney at Law, Fisher Phillips
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“David assisted our client who had been denied insurance coverage due to a policy change. David represents those who are insured and may not receive coverage benefits when needed. He’s an excellent communicator and always follows up with clients. He’s also aggressive when needed and practical. When it comes to matters of insurance benefit denials, David is excellent in these cases and helps to get those insured the coverage they need.”
Kevin J. Moore
KJM Law Partners
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“I don't know what it is about insurance companies. In good faith we bought the top Travel package for a Safari in east Africa. When I got severely sick, we headed home. I never thought our claim would be denied. I hired David Scheidemantle to fight and fight he and associate Katherine Fayne did. 15 months and they never gave up. They continued to push up the food chain, negotiated a settlement & I received the cost of the Safari and the legal costs. I'm so grateful for their expertise.”
Arthur F. (“Christoper”) Law III
Duma African Safaris LLC
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“So finally, I meet you, mellow but razor sharp, part of the solution not problem, and a legal warrior in an area that for so many has become viscerally annoying! When I think of the money spent, time spent, lack of any material reimbursement, and the crap I went through helping my in-laws with insurance, meeting you would have been a breath of fresh air even if you hadn’t been so charming. So there!”
Tom Broadbent
Expense Reduction Analysts
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“David Scheidemantle represented us after our RV insurance company denied our claim for an engine fire that caused extensive damage. David and his firm worked tirelessly on our behalf, resulting in a very fair and favorable outcome for us. David has superior knowledge of the law, advocates for the underdog, is a wonderful strategist and has excellent communication skills. David cares about his clients and you know you are #1 in his book. You cannot go wrong hiring David and his team. We will recommend him any chance we can.”
Michael and Misty Moravec
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
“For a number of years, David has represented me in business and personal matters. I found him to be highly effective at problem assessment, analysis, conflict resolution and client interface. He is insightful, particularly good at understanding competing points of view and crafting comprehensive solutions. David is fully committed to his clients and unfailingly, delivers good outcomes quickly. I highly recommend him as an individual and attorney.”
Teri Unsworth
Vice President, Marketing, Guest Supply, LLC, a division of Sysco Corporation (retired) .